Every gamer has that one game. The game that made them throw a controller, rage-quit, or scream at their screen. The game that was so frustrating it became legendary. I’ve played my share of infuriating games, and I’ve come to appreciate that there’s a difference between “challenging” and “annoying.” Challenging games respect your time. Annoying games waste it. Here are the most annoying games I’ve ever played, and what makes them cross the line from hard to unfair.
Updated April 2026.
Getting Over It with Bennett Foddy
This game is designed to be annoying. You control a man in a cauldron using a sledgehammer to climb a mountain. One mistake can send you falling back to the beginning. I played for 8 hours, fell near the top, and lost 45 minutes of progress. I closed the game and didn’t open it for a month. But here’s the thing: Getting Over It is annoying by design. The frustration IS the game. Bennett Foddy’s commentary plays as you climb, and it’s clear he knows exactly what he’s doing. This game is annoying in a way that’s intentional, artistic, and kind of brilliant. I still hate it.
Dark Souls II
Dark Souls 1 and 3 are challenging. Dark Souls II is annoying. The difference: DS1 and DS3 kill you because you made a mistake. DS2 kills you because of bad design. Hit boxes are inconsistent, enemies track your movements unrealistically, and the ADP stat makes dodging unreliable until you level it. I died to the Ruin Sentinels 30 times because my iframes didn’t activate despite visually dodging. That’s not challenge — that’s bad mechanics. DS2 has good ideas (power stancing, build variety) buried under frustrating design. I finished it once and never went back.
Super Meat Boy
Super Meat Boy is hard but fair. Every death is your fault. The controls are tight, the levels are well-designed, and respawning is instant. I died 1,200 times in the Light World and I was rarely frustrated. The key: zero loading time between deaths. You die, you’re back. No waiting, no loading, no penalty. This is how hard games should work. Super Meat Boy is the opposite of annoying — it’s challenging done right.
Ninja Gaiden (2004)
The original Xbox Ninja Gaiden is one of the hardest games ever made, and it crosses into annoying territory regularly. Alma, the boss, took me 50+ attempts. The camera is terrible, the difficulty spikes are brutal, and some encounters feel like the developers wanted to punish you. I beat it eventually, but I didn’t enjoy large portions of it. There’s a line between “satisfyingly difficult” and “sadistic,” and Ninja Gaiden crosses it repeatedly.
I Wanna Be The Guy
This is the most annoying game ever made, and it knows it. Apples fall upward. Save points kill you. Bosses appear without warning. Everything is designed to trick and kill you. I played for 2 hours and died 500 times. It’s a parody of difficult games — the annoyance is the joke. I respect the commitment to chaos, but I didn’t enjoy playing it. Some games are annoying as a statement. I Wanna Be The Guy is that statement.
What Makes a Game “Annoying” vs “Challenging”
After playing all of these, I’ve identified the difference:
- Challenging: You die because you made a mistake. You learn and improve. (Super Meat Boy, Celeste, Sekiro)
- Annoying: You die because of bad design. You can’t learn or improve because the problem isn’t your skill. (DS2 hitboxes, bad cameras, unfair difficulty spikes)
The test: Can I identify what I did wrong and do better next time? If yes, it’s challenging. If no, it’s annoying. I don’t mind dying 100 times if each death teaches me something. I mind dying once to a bad camera angle.
My Final Thoughts
The most annoying game I’ve ever played is Getting Over It — but it’s annoying on purpose, which makes it art. The most unfairly annoying game is Dark Souls II — it’s annoying by accident, which makes it frustrating. The best hard game I’ve played is Celeste — it’s challenging but never annoying, with tight controls, instant respawns, and fair difficulty. If you want to suffer, play Getting Over It. If you want to improve, play Celeste.
Continue reading:
